Is Star Trek: Voyager good... or is it garbage? Journey forward to the courtroom of the Honorable Judge Midnightien Later as he seeks to discern a final and legally-binding answer to this and other perplexing questions, one Voyager episode at a time. Is Janeway the purest exemplar of the overarching Star Trek ethos, or does she personify the dangers of dogmatic adherence to Starfleet’s institutional code? Is the Voyager a pretty ship? Why does the theme song never speed up? The court’s only hope for finding answers are three voices from the ancient past: The apologist, the hater, and the dude who is watching it all for the first time.

Case 8.05: Season Eight - Rise - The Season Three Appeal
Rise (2022) · Jul 27, 2026

Special Presentation: The People v. Firefly - Case 03: Bushwhacked
Bushwhacked (1995) · Nov 16, 2025

Special Presentation: The People v. Firefly - Case 01: Serenity
Serenity (2005) · Nov 5, 2025

Case 7.24: Renaissance Man
Renaissance Man (1994) · Jan 20, 2024

Case 7.5: Critical Care
Critical Care (1997) · May 13, 2023

Case 4.14: Message in a Bottle
Message in a Bottle (1999) · Apr 22, 2020

Case 3.4: The Swarm
The Swarm (1978) · Feb 28, 2019

Case 2.23: The Thaw
The Thaw (2009) · Sep 15, 2018

Case 1.12: Heroes and Demons
Heroes and Demons (2012) · Jan 3, 2018

Case 1.07: Eye of the Needle
Eye of the Needle (1981) · Nov 8, 2017
