Each week we take a nostalgic film and put it on trial. One of us is the judge. One of us is the prosecution. One of us is the defense.
Vertical Limit
Vertical Limit (2000) · Sep 3, 2026
George of the Jungle
George of the Jungle (1997) · Aug 20, 2026
Super Troopers
Super Troopers (2001) · Aug 6, 2026
Mystery Men
Mystery Men (1999) · Jul 30, 2026
Spider-Man 3
Spider-Man 3 (2007) · Jul 23, 2026
Evil Dead (1981)
The Evil Dead (1981) · Jul 16, 2026
Scary Movie
Scary Movie (2000) · Jul 9, 2026
Independence Day
Independence Day (1996) · Jul 2, 2026
The Faculty (With Guest Judge Chris Bramante)
The Faculty (1998) · Mar 26, 2026
Face/Off (With Guest Judge Bob Pilson - A.K.A Dave's Dad)
Face/Off (1997) · Mar 19, 2026
The Transporter (With Guest Judge Sean Brogan)
The Transporter (2002) · Mar 12, 2026
What Dreams May Come (With Guest Judge Mike Ellis)
What Dreams May Come (1998) · Mar 5, 2026
Vegas Vacation (With Guest Judge Alex Metz)
Vegas Vacation (1997) · Feb 26, 2026
The Re-Trial of Hook (With Guest Defense George Chammas)
Hook (1991) · Feb 19, 2026
Failure to Launch
Failure to Launch (2006) · Feb 12, 2026
Charlie's Angels
Charlie's Angels (2000) · Feb 5, 2026
Goldeneye (With Witness Nate Caywood)
GoldenEye (1995) · Jan 29, 2026
Signs (With Witness Miles Crosman)
Signs (2002) · Jan 22, 2026
The Mask (With Witness Jon Salmon)
The Mask (1994) · Jan 15, 2026
Seabiscuit (With Witness Isabelle Bright)
Seabiscuit (2003) · Jan 8, 2026
Poseidon (With Witness Brandon Baker)
Poseidon (2006) · Jan 1, 2026
Eight Crazy Nights (With Witness Dave Newberg)
Eight Crazy Nights (2002) · Dec 18, 2025
Jingle All The Way (With Witness John Schuta)
Jingle All the Way (1996) · Dec 11, 2025
The Santa Clause (With Witness Kirk Thatcher)
The Santa Clause (1994) · Dec 4, 2025
The Waterboy (With Witness Josh George)
The Waterboy (1998) · Nov 20, 2025
Anaconda (With Witness Billie Wolff)
Anaconda (1997) · Nov 13, 2025
The Hitchhikers Guide To the Galaxy (With Witness Patrick Cotnoir)
The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy (2005) · Nov 6, 2025
The Grudge (With Witness Mike Garcia)
The Grudge (2004) · Oct 30, 2025
House On Haunted Hill (With Witness Mike Sutter)
House on Haunted Hill (1999) · Oct 23, 2025
The Blair Witch Project (With Witness Alex Henes)
The Blair Witch Project (1999) · Oct 16, 2025
Hostel (With Witness Matt Reynolds)
Hostel (2006) · Oct 9, 2025
Rat Race (Live Episode!!) With Witness Terry Matalas
Rat Race (2001) · Sep 25, 2025
Romeo + Juliet (With Witness Eric "Slip" Peterson
Romeo + Juliet (1996) · Sep 18, 2025
Lost in Space (With Witness Alex Galbate)
Lost in Space (1998) · Sep 11, 2025
The Texas Chainsaw Massacre (With Witness Jess Defanti)
The Texas Chainsaw Massacre (2003) · Sep 4, 2025
Shanghai Noon (With Witness Trey Callaway)
Shanghai Noon (2000) · Aug 28, 2025
High School Musical (With Witness Branson Nejame)
High School Musical (2006) · Aug 21, 2025
Identity (With Witness Steve Rommevaux)
Identity (2003) · Aug 14, 2025
Freaky Friday (With Witness Isabel Galupo)
Freaky Friday (2003) · Aug 7, 2025
The Perfect Storm (With Witness Sean Brogan)
The Perfect Storm (2000) · Jul 31, 2025
The Fountain (With Witness Steve Markowitz)
The Fountain (2006) · Jul 24, 2025
Across the Universe (With Witness Danny Gendron)
Across the Universe (2007) · Jul 17, 2025
Coyote Ugly (With Witness Kat Primeau)
Coyote Ugly (2000) · Jul 10, 2025
The Patriot (With Witness Eric Carlson)
The Patriot (2000) · Jul 3, 2025
Star Wars: Episode 1 - The Phantom Menace (With Witness Bobby Lopez)
Star Wars: Episode I - The Phantom Menace (1999) · Jun 26, 2025
Last Action Hero (With Witness Jason Hellerman)
Last Action Hero (1993) · Jun 19, 2025
Black Knight (With Witness Opey Olagbaju)
Black Knight (2001) · Jun 12, 2025
The Time Machine (With Witness Mike Ellis)
The Time Machine (1960) · Jun 5, 2025
National Treasure (With Witness Sam Elhindi)
National Treasure (2004) · May 29, 2025
The Brady Bunch Movie (With Witness David Silverman)
The Brady Bunch Movie (1995) · May 22, 2025
What Women Want (With Witness Kate Anderson)
What Women Want (2000) · May 15, 2025
Joe Dirt (With Witness George Chammas)
Joe Dirt (2001) · May 8, 2025
Bedazzled (With Witness Wyatt Cain)
Bedazzled (2000) · May 1, 2025
Can't Hardly Wait (With Witness Topher Grace)
Can't Hardly Wait (1998) · Apr 24, 2025
Click (With Witness Alex Metz)
Click (2006) · Apr 17, 2025
Godzilla (1998)
Godzilla (1998) · Apr 10, 2025
Eurotrip UNRATED (With Witness Evan Moore)
EuroTrip (2004) · Apr 3, 2025
The Butterfly Effect (With Witness Chris Bramante)
The Butterfly Effect (2004) · Mar 27, 2025
Vanilla Sky (With Witness Schuyler Brumley)
Vanilla Sky (2001) · Mar 20, 2025
Deep Blue Sea
Deep Blue Sea (1999) · Mar 13, 2025
Blast From the Past (With Witness Jennifer Muro)
Blast from the Past (1999) · Mar 6, 2025
Hollow Man (With Witness Michael Giacchino)
Hollow Man (2000) · Feb 27, 2025
Saving Silverman (With Witness Tom McGovern)
Saving Silverman (2001) · Feb 20, 2025
Hitch (Valentines Day Special With Kate Anderson + Leana Courtney)
Hitch (2005) · Feb 13, 2025
Any Given Sunday (With Witness Marc Sessler)
Any Given Sunday (1999) · Feb 6, 2025
Miss Congeniality (With Witness Mckenzie Goodwin)
Miss Congeniality (2000) · Jan 30, 2025
The Princess Diaries (With Witness Leana Courtney)
The Princess Diaries (2001) · Jan 23, 2025
Bruce Almighty
Bruce Almighty (2003) · Jan 16, 2025
Antz (With Witness Luke Null)
Antz (1998) · Jan 9, 2025
Love Actually
Love Actually (2003) · Dec 19, 2024
Jack Frost
Jack Frost (1998) · Dec 12, 2024
The Replacements
The Replacements (2000) · Nov 28, 2024
Cruel Intentions
Cruel Intentions (1999) · Nov 21, 2024
Space Jam
Space Jam (1996) · Nov 14, 2024
Napoleon Dynamite
Napoleon Dynamite (2004) · Nov 7, 2024
Jeepers Creepers (With Witness Alex Henes)
Jeepers Creepers (2001) · Oct 31, 2024
Armageddon
Armageddon (1998) · Oct 24, 2024
Bring It On
Bring It On (2000) · Oct 17, 2024
A Knight's Tale (with Witness George Chammas)
A Knight's Tale (2001) · Oct 10, 2024
Small Soldiers
Small Soldiers (1998) · Oct 3, 2024